The following is a summary of the Hydrogen Roundtable discussion at the Climate Tech Investment Conference during NYC Climate Week. Below is a summary of the comments by Justin Milberg, Investment manager for KVC Catalyst, a Hydrogen dedicated hedge fund based in New York.
In recent years, hydrogen has been hailed as a promising solution for decarbonizing heavy industries, transportation, and power sectors. Companies like Plug Power were initially viewed as leading the charge in the hydrogen revolution, much like Tesla was in the electric vehicle market. However, the hydrogen sector has faced significant setbacks, including regulatory uncertainty, high production costs, and competition from cheaper energy sources like natural gas. These factors have contributed to a fluctuating investment landscape and market volatility. An analysis of these challenges provides insights into the future direction of the hydrogen economy.
Commercial Setbacks: The Case of Plug Power
At the peak of the hydrogen excitement in January 2021, Plug Power's stock soared to $72 per share. Yet, as of late 2023, it had plummeted to just $2, illustrating the sector's volatility. Three primary dynamics contributed to this decline:
Inflation and Production Costs: The cost of producing hydrogen significantly increased during the COVID-19 pandemic, making it a less competitive energy source. The resulting inflation impacted not only the price of hydrogen but also the capital expenditure for building and maintaining hydrogen production facilities.
Regulatory Hurdles: The hydrogen industry has been hampered by a lack of regulatory clarity. It has taken years for governments to establish policies and permitting processes for hydrogen plants, causing substantial project delays. The global debate over the definition of "clean hydrogen" has further complicated investment decisions, as companies have been unable to proceed without knowing the regulatory framework they would be operating under.
Natural Gas Price Declines: The drop in natural gas prices since 2021 has made hydrogen a less attractive alternative fuel source. This shift has dampened enthusiasm for hydrogen, particularly in sectors where cost competition is a critical factor.
The Need for Regulatory Certainty
The demand for clear regulatory guidelines is a recurring theme. Many companies, such as Air Products, have opted to delay investments in green hydrogen facilities due to regulatory ambiguity. As one industry expert noted, "Even unfavorable regulations would be better than living in this era of uncertainty." The situation exemplifies the need for consistent and predictable policies to support large-scale hydrogen adoption.
Progress Amid Challenges: The Green Hydrogen Push
Despite these challenges, there are reasons for cautious optimism. Since October 2023, the hydrogen sector has seen a 60% increase in the deployment of electrolyzers globally, according to the latest report from the Hydrogen Council. A significant portion of this growth is being driven by China, which accounts for about 60% of new electrolyzer installations.
Notable developments include:
Plug Power’s Georgia Plant: Plug Power recently ramped up production at its Georgia facility, which is now operating at full capacity. This plant, the first of its kind to utilize 100% solar power for liquid hydrogen production, supplies fuel for forklifts used in Amazon and Walmart’s logistics operations.
Major Orders for Electrolyzers in Europe: Siemens Energy recently secured orders for 380 MW of electrolyzers, more than the combined global orders prior to these deals. This shift signals that some of the headwinds facing the hydrogen industry are beginning to abate.
Emerging Solutions and the Role of Blue Hydrogen
The debate between blue and green hydrogen remains contentious. While green hydrogen is produced using renewable energy, blue hydrogen is derived from natural gas with carbon capture technology. Critics argue that blue hydrogen is less sustainable due to methane leaks and lower carbon capture efficiency. However, blue hydrogen is currently being adopted at a faster rate due to its lower costs and existing infrastructure.
One notable initiative is Bloom Energy’s “Responsible Natural Gas” program, which aims to ensure that natural gas used in blue hydrogen production comes from suppliers with strict methane leakage controls. Such efforts highlight the ongoing evolution of industry standards and the attempt to balance cost and sustainability.
Hydrogen as a Fuel Carrier: The Role of Ammonia
Ammonia, a compound of hydrogen and nitrogen, has emerged as a viable hydrogen carrier, especially in the shipping industry. With existing logistics systems in place for ammonia transport, it provides a dense and efficient means of storing and shipping hydrogen. This development is particularly promising for sectors like maritime shipping, where hydrogen adoption has faced significant technical and economic barriers.
Looking Forward: Key Takeaways and Future Outlook
The hydrogen industry is at a critical juncture. While regulatory uncertainty, cost competition, and technology constraints have hindered progress, recent developments suggest that momentum is building. The sharp rise in electrolyzer deployments and new projects coming online in 2025 indicate that the sector may be turning a corner.
However, achieving the full potential of hydrogen as a clean energy source will require continued policy support, technological advancements, and large-scale investments. As Milberg summed up, “The giant headwinds are starting to ameliorate, but it is still a very long road ahead.”
The ongoing evolution of the hydrogen market underscores the need for careful monitoring of policy changes, cost trends, and technological innovations. With continued collaboration and strategic investments, hydrogen could play a central role in the global energy transition.
References:
Summary Report of Hydrogen Council Report 2023
Market Analysis Reports on Green and Blue Hydrogen Deployments
Industry Insights from Plug Power, Siemens Energy, and Bloom Energy
Kommentarer